1. Four Seas, Centerville, Massachusetts
Located a short stroll from Cape Cod’s Barnstable beaches, the venerable Four Seas Ice Cream took over a former blacksmith shop in 1934 to dish up New England favorites such as penuche pecan (based on the brown sugar fudge recipe of local grandmothers) and fresh peach, the Kennedy family’s summertime favorite.
2. Moomers, Traverse City, Michigan
The annual National Cherry Festival tarts up this Lake Michigan town during July harvest season, but pastoral Moomers always churns farm-fresh ice cream made with milk from its cows; several flavors are studded with northern Michigan black cherries.
3. Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream, New York CIty, New York
This Lower East Side parlor opened in 2014, and the soda-fountain counter has been full ever since. Made in small batches, the egg-free ice cream comes in 40 flavors, including four chocolate varieties (Szechuan peppercorn, bitter, salted, and peanut butter). Try them all in the King Kong banana split.
4. Kermit’s Key West Lime Shoppe, Key West, Florida
Overlooking the historic seaport, Kermit’s colorful corner shop is as green as the famous frog himself. Signature frozen treats include key lime ice cream and dark-chocolate-covered frozen key lime pie slices on a stick.
5. Matsumoto Shave Ice, Haleiwa, Hawaii
On hot sunny days, Matsumoto doles out about 1,000 servings of Japanese shave ice (kakigori) streaked with colorful, homemade syrups in flavors like coconut, lychee, and papaya to locals, surfers, and travelers lined up at the 1951 grocery store along Oahu’s North Shore.
6. Doumar’s, Norfolk, Virginia
When an ice cream vendor ran out of bowls at the 1904 St. Louis World’s Fair, Syrian immigrant Abe Doumar loaded the cold treat into rolled up waffles, then built the first waffle iron (still in use), and opened Doumar’s Cones and Barbecue near Virginia Beach. In 1934, innovative Abe introduced curbside service still provided at the historic diner today.